From
the Providence
Journal, Monday, July 6, 2007.
IN AN ECONOMY that’s producing fiscal
surplus for most of America, Rhode Island is projected
to continue facing enormous deficits for the foreseeable
future because the state’s expenditures are growing
faster than the revenue being generated. And for this
tremendous debt we’ve gotten very little in return.
Rhode Island social-service expenditures
are among the highest in the country, even though we
lag behind the nation in reducing poverty. Our public-education
system also spends more per capita than most other states,
yet academic achievement ranks below average. High taxes
and burdensome regulations make for an environment in
which many large companies are willing to do business
in our state only if they are awarded special deals,
while the smaller businesses are left to fend for themselves,
if they survive at all.
Many politicians and citizens recognize
that this results from legislation tailored for “special-interest
groups.” This is the problem of faction that America’s
Founders anticipated. In the trenches, this amounts to
complaints that the legislature lacks a coherent opposition,
that all branches of government have their own agenda
shaped by themselves and their closest advisers. But,
this reasoning assumes that we live in a world of constant “market
failure,” in which private action can’t solve
problems and the government must be the deus ex machina
puppet-master of our existence.
While concerns about a lack of access to
education and welfare, exploitative workplace practices,
and the environmental consequences of development have
legitimate foundations in America’s and Rhode Island’s
history, there are sound arguments for government to
constantly revisit the possibility of abstaining from
arenas where individual liberty and personal responsibility
work better.
As the Founders well understood, government
in moderation is beneficial, but excessive government
inevitably impinges upon individual liberty, fostering
dependence rather than empowering prosperity.
Ironically, Rhode Island is stuck in a “conservative” cycle
protecting the “liberal” status quo of excessive
workplace rules, generous social programs, retentive
regulation, entrenched unionism in state government and
Horace Mann’s approach to education. Harking to
the days of the Dorr War (1842) and the Bloodless Revolution
(1935), our oligarchy is unwilling to risk the progress
it has made by reassessing these circumstances lest the
robber barons should rise from their graves.
A voice for a more independent perspective
has been missing on the Rhode Island scene until this
Independence Day heralded the founding of the Ocean State
Policy Research Institute. This nonprofit foundation
intends to promote free-market ideals not as partisan
choices, but as foundational American aspirations no
less worthy of consideration than socially collective
compassion epitomized by the Great Society.
Rhode Island is replete with a collection
of “special-interest groups” promoting government
intervention as the solution. Such groups as the Poverty
Institute, at Rhode Island College, Ocean State Action
and other nonprofits and public institutions lobby for
more government programs and spending. Paradoxically,
your taxes fund part of this activity, effectively government
lobbying itself in a spiral to budget insanity.
Of course, lobbying is by no means limited
to promoters of populist redistribution. Businesses,
social services and labor unions alike advance their
own interests by lobbying government, more often than
not for particularized solutions of interest to their
sector or their particular firm, and without regard to
the impact upon the economy and society as a whole.
Principled interests on both sides, if
truly supporting the pursuit of happiness by Rhode Island
citizens, should support serious analysis of when and
where government action is, or is not, the best avenue
for improvement of our quality of life. Evidence from
the solid accomplishments of free-market institutes in
46 other states suggests that Rhode Island should re-examine
the prevailing ‘’wisdom” that expanding
government is the way to solve problems.
We are proud to dedicate “our lives,
our property and our sacred honor” to invigorating
that discussion, taking up the pen if not the sword in
the tradition of those who so declared on July 4, 1776.
Please join the Ocean State Policy Research Institute
in welcoming its charter fellows, who will advance the
institute’s mission of crafting sound policies
based on the principles of free enterprise, limited government,
and traditional American values through timely research
on important issues to be shared with elected officials,
the media, business leaders, community organizations
and individual citizens:
Fellow for Economic Development: Edward
Mazze, Ph.D.; Fellow for Regulatory and Environmental
Policy: Brian Bishop; Fellows for Educational and Social
Welfare Policy: Robert Ledermann, Ph. D., David Anderson,
Ph.D., and William Felkner.
But, of course, we are not alone in our
battle for reform. Ocean State Policy intends to collaborate
with other national, statewide and local-issue organizations
through the formation of the Rhode Island Center Right
Coalition. We don’t always have common goals but
have a common interest in thinking outside of the box.
We must expect less from our government
and more from ourselves, and when government does intervene,
it must be efficient, effective and uphold the values
of our culture. We believe that advancing these principles
will ensure that Rhode Island remains a vital home for
our children and grandchildren.